Documents to download

On 19 October 2020, the second reading of the United Kingdom Internal Market Bill is scheduled to take place in the House of Lords.

The existing UK internal market is supported by EU law that still has effect through the operation of the transition period. When the transition period ends at the end of December 2020, the Government has argued that legislation is required to ensure the internal market continues to function smoothly. For example, the bill includes provision for market access principles of mutual recognition and non-discrimination for goods and services.

The bill also seeks to ensure unfettered access for qualifying Northern Ireland goods to the rest of the UK market. The Government argues the EU is seeking to implement aspects of the Northern Ireland Protocol in ways that were not originally intended, in order to gain leverage in the future relationship negotiations. To create what the Government calls a “legal safety net” against this, clauses 44, 45 and 57 of the bill seek to give ministers the power to unilaterally interpret, modify the application of or disapply parts of the Northern Ireland Protocol, notwithstanding their obligations under relevant international and domestic law. These provisions have been controversial.

The Scottish and Welsh Governments have objected to the bill’s proposals and argue that the bill goes against the devolution settlements. The Scottish Parliament has voted to withhold legislative consent for the bill, and the Welsh Government has recommended that the Senedd Cymru withholds consent. The Northern Ireland Assembly has indicated that it wants to oppose the bill.

The EU has launched infringement proceedings against the UK, claiming that the bill breaches the UK’s obligation under article 5 of the withdrawal agreement to act in good faith in implementing the agreement.

In response to concerns about clauses 44, 45 and 47 breaching the UK’s international obligations, the Government made an amendment at committee stage to introduce a ‘break glass’ provision so these clauses could not come into force without the Commons’ approval. Government amendments on judicial review would allow a three-month window for claims to be brought against regulations made under clauses 44 and 45; the courts could make a declaration of incompatibility with the Human Right Act 1998 in respect of such regulations, but could not strike them down. The Government also made technical and drafting amendments. No opposition amendments were made to the bill.


Documents to download

Related posts

  • Government’s ‘green book’: Review and reforms

    The Government’s ‘green book’ is guidance on how to appraise public sector policies, programmes and projects. In January 2025, the Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves announced a review of the green book. The review’s conclusions were published in June 2025 and are designed to improve the effectiveness of public sector appraisal. The Treasury will release an updated green book in early 2026.

    Government’s ‘green book’: Review and reforms
  • AI and creative technology scaleups: Communications and Digital Committee report

    In September 2024 the House of Lords Communications and Digital Committee launched an inquiry into the scaleup challenges facing startup enterprises working with artificial intelligence (AI) and creative technology. In a report published in February 2025, the committee warned the UK risked becoming an incubator economy where UK startups developed innovative products and services before selling out or moving abroad. This briefing summarises the report’s recommendations and the government’s response.

    AI and creative technology scaleups: Communications and Digital Committee report
  • Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill: HL Bill 96 of 2024–25

    The government has committed to reducing and reclaiming public money lost to fraud and error. The Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill contains provisions to extend Cabinet Office and Public Sector Fraud Authority powers to tackle fraud and error outside the tax and benefits system, and also expands powers to tackle fraud within the benefits system. The bill is due to have its second reading in the House of Lords on 15 May 2025.

    Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill: HL Bill 96 of 2024–25