Documents to download

On 23 May 2019, the House of Lords is due to debate a motion moved by Lord Brown of Eaton-under Heywood (Crossbench) that “this House takes note of the potential conflict between the right of members to speak freely in Parliament and the obligation under the rule of law to obey court orders”. Lord Brown is a former justice of the Supreme Court.

Freedom of speech is a key element of parliamentary privilege, which is guaranteed by article 9 of the Bill of Rights of 1689. MPs and Members of the House of Lords have legal immunity for what they say or do during proceedings in Parliament. However, both Houses have passed sub judice resolutions which limit the discussion in Parliament of ongoing legal cases. This is intended to maintain an appropriate balance between the respective constitutional roles of Parliament and the courts.

On occasion, parliamentarians have used parliamentary privilege to disclose information in Parliament that was subject to a court order intended to prevent the dissemination of that information. Generally, someone who knowingly breaches the terms of such a court order could run the risk of being found in contempt of court. However, parliamentary privilege means that this does not apply to information disclosed in parliamentary proceedings. This has raised issues where a parliamentarian has revealed a name protected by a court order and it is subsequently repeated in the media, particularly in cases where proceedings were still active. There have been several reviews of whether Parliament should change its own internal rules on the use of parliamentary privilege to breach court orders. To date, the conclusion has been that it would not be necessary unless the frequency of such cases were to increase. Some of these reviews also identified practical difficulties in implementing rules to further restrain freedom of speech in parliamentary proceedings.

The purpose of this briefing is not to go into detail about any specific cases that have occurred. Rather, it explores the underlying principles and sets out the findings of parliamentary committees that have previously examined the subject.

Documents to download

Related posts

  • Pride in the UK: 50 years

    On 1 July 1972 the UK’s first Pride march was held in London. This date was chosen as the nearest Saturday to the anniversary of the riots, or uprising, at the Stonewall Inn in 1969, where LGBT+ patrons had been targeted by the New York Police Department. Liberation organisations were inspired to action, and Pride marches have since become annual events throughout the UK and around the world.

    Pride in the UK: 50 years
  • Draft environmental principles policy statement

    The Environment Act 2021 requires the government to publish an environmental principles policy statement outlining how environmental principles should be interpreted and applied by ministers when making policy. A draft of the first statement to be made under the act was laid before Parliament on 11 May 2022 and is due to be discussed by the Lords on 30 June 2022.

    Draft environmental principles policy statement