Documents to download

new version of this briefing has been published, including updated content covering developments up to 8 February 2019.

Following the Government’s defeat in the ‘meaningful vote’ on 15 January 2019, further Brexit debates took place in the Lords and the Commons on 28 and 29 January 2019 respectively. This was in accordance with section 13 of the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 (EUWA) which sets out what must happen next if the Government fails to win approval for its Brexit deal in the House of Commons.

On 28 January 2019, the Lords agreed by a majority of 152 to a Labour motion calling on the Government to take all appropriate steps to ensure the UK does not leave without a deal, and to provide sufficient time in the Lords to pass legislation to implement any deal that has majority support in the Commons. The following day, the Commons voted by a majority of 16 in favour of a backbench amendment supported by the Government to replace the Northern Ireland backstop with “alternative arrangements to avoid a hard border”. The Prime Minister said this gave her a mandate to reopen negotiations with the EU to seek legally binding changes to the withdrawal agreement. However, doubts have been expressed about what “alternative arrangements” could replace the backstop, and the EU has maintained that the withdrawal agreement is not open for renegotiation.

The Commons also voted by a majority of eight in favour of an amendment rejecting the UK leaving the EU with no deal. However, this amendment cannot change the law or bind the Government or the EU to a particular course of action. Other amendments, including ones seeking an extension to the article 50 negotiating period, were defeated.

The Prime Minister said she intended to bring a revised deal back to the Commons for a “second meaningful vote” as soon as possible. If the Commons did not support that deal, she said the Government would table an amendable motion for debate the next day. If the Government has not brought back a revised deal by 13 February 2019, the Prime Minister said she would make a statement that day and table an amendable motion for debate the next day.

Prior to the Commons debate of 29 January 2019, the Leader of the House of Lords indicated the Lords would have the opportunity to respond to the outcome of any votes in the Commons. If the Government brings back a revised deal, section 13(1) of the EUWA requires a ‘take note’ motion to be tabled in the Lords; if the Commons approved that deal, the Lords would also have a role in passing legislation to implement a withdrawal agreement in domestic legislation, which must happen before the agreement could be ratified. If the Commons rejected a deal in a second meaningful vote, a further ‘take note’ debate would need to be scheduled in the Lords under section 13(6) of the EUWA.

Documents to download

Related posts

  • UK position on foreign affairs

    In 2021 the government published an integrated review of security, defence, development and foreign policy. It published a refreshed review in March 2023 to take account of developments in foreign affairs over the preceding two years. The government has since published a number of policy papers and strategies to complement the refreshed review. In addition, Lord Cameron of Chipping Norton was appointed as foreign secretary in November 2023.

    UK position on foreign affairs
  • Supporting Myanmar’s health system

    A military coup in Myanmar in February 2021 has led to widespread conflict and has had a severe impact on its health care system. Many health care workers have been involved in civil disobedience and protests against the coup, including boycotts. Organisations such as the WHO and Insecurity Insight have also reported on attacks on health care in the country. Since February 2021, the UK government has provided over £120mn in humanitarian and development assistance in Myanmar.

    Supporting Myanmar’s health system
  • Questions to the foreign secretary: 13 February 2024

    Members of the House of Lords will ask Foreign Secretary Lord Cameron of Chipping Norton a series of oral questions on 13 February 2024. These include what discussions the government has had with partners on a strategy to reduce debt in the developing world; what the UK is doing to protect children in Gaza; what progress the government has made in implementing the AUKUS security partnership; and UK-US discussions on recognising a Palestinian state.

    Questions to the foreign secretary: 13 February 2024