Documents to download

Governments legislate for a variety of reasons, such as: to implement manifesto commitments; to reverse the policies of previous governments; to reflect new policies in response to events or changing circumstances; to raise revenue and authorise expenditure; to give effect to international commitments; and for departmental ‘housekeeping’.  Periodically, concerns have been raised about the volume of new legislation introduced. Lord Framlingham (Conservative) has tabled a question for short debate on 8 September about whether the Government plans to consider the proposal that, for a period of time, all government departments should cease devising new legislation and concentrate on sound administration.

While the average number of Acts has slightly declined over the past 40 years, the number of Statutory Instruments has increased (although there was a fall in the number of SIs in 2015). Calculating the size of the statute book in terms of the number of pages of legislation is not straightforward for methodological reasons and because of changes in drafting styles and publishing practices over time. However, the Office of the Parliamentary Counsel concluded in 2013 that the average length of Bills was “significantly greater than in previous decades”, and a former Parliamentary Counsel calculated in 2016 that while the number of Acts passed by governments had stayed approximately the same over the past 50 years, the average number of clauses included within them had doubled.

The Cabinet Office Guide to Making Legislation sets out guidance to departmental bill teams on preparing primary legislation.  Departments are advised to “consider whether primary legislation is necessary” and “whether the ends they wish to achieve could be reached by purely administrative means” before bidding for a slot in the legislative programme. Departments are also expected to comply with the Office of the Parliamentary Counsel’s principles that ‘good law’ should be necessary, clear, coherent, effective and accessible.  The House of Commons Political and Constitutional Reform Committee and two House of Lords working groups have all proposed in recent years that a Legislative Standards Committee should be established, but these proposals have not been taken forward.


Documents to download

Related posts

  • Education (Assemblies) Bill [HL]:HL Bill 35 of 2024-25

    The Education (Assemblies) Bill [HL] is a private member’s bill introduced by Baroness Burt of Solihull (Liberal Democrat). It would repeal the requirement for schools in England without a designated religious character to provide daily acts of collective religious worship. In its place, the bill would establish a new duty to provide non-religious assemblies which develop the spiritual, moral, social, and cultural education of pupils.

    Education (Assemblies) Bill [HL]:HL Bill 35 of 2024-25
  • Terrorism in the UK: Legislation and government strategy

    The UK’s approach to counter-terrorism is set out in its strategy CONTEST, which includes the scheme Prevent. Following the Southport attack in July 2024, Keir Starmer said that the threat from terrorism had changed, and the government would be reviewing its counter-extremism systems and reforming programmes such as Prevent. He also said the government would change the law to respond to the new threat if needed.

    Terrorism in the UK: Legislation and government strategy
  • Office attendance mandate for the civil service

    The Conservative government set an expectation that civil servants spend at least 60% of their working week at a government building or on official business. The Labour government has maintained this expectation due to the “clear benefits of face-to-face working”. Some civil servants have raised concerns about the 60% office attendance mandate, including civil servants in HM Land Registry who have recently voted in favour of strike action.

    Office attendance mandate for the civil service